Madison Fashion Weak?
By: Maggie Dolan
June 13th, 2008
Putting on a fashion week in Madison is about as awkward as deer hunting in Manhattan. Yet, unlike the impossibility of hunting game in NYC, apparently, a fashion week in Madison is achievable. Though an obvious sense of uncertainty is felt when putting the words, fashion and Madison, in the same sentence.
The ambivalence stems from the fact that the two entities barely know each other and people rarely dare to introduce them. Living in the Midwest, you think we’d be used to hearing "fashion" said with discretion. It wasn't even until 2006 that Chicago, the Midwest's honorary fashion capitol, finally began hosting their own fashion week. And, just two years later, the Midwestern metropolis known better for cheese than clothes, followed suit.
In April 2008, Madison, Wisconsin held their very own fashion week. Runways, models, after parties and all! I was there, intrigued, hopeful and still apprehensive.
To make one thing clear, it wasn’t so much a fashion week as it was an extended weekend of fashion-inspired events. Workshops including, “Careers in Fashion”, “Celebrity Styling” and “Runway Ready Hair”, were intertwined with two runway events and an accessories show.
The main event was on a Saturday. Upon arrival I scanned the room to see what I was in for. Immediately, I noticed the sod-laden runway, which quickly went from charming to cheap. As I took my seat, I glanced over at my fellow front-rowers. I was overwhelmed with the lack of fashion forward youth. Isn’t that who the front row is for?
Instead, there was an abundance of “over 35” ladies dressed in poly-blend blouses and flared black pants, adorned in gobs of silver jewelry. Not that I think fashion should have an age limit but the entire week(end) seemed to lack the innovative youth culture that Madison is built on.
Down the row, I finally spotted a fellow fashionista. The woman, probably from out of town, wore a crisp white trench coat, black skirt, tights and heels. Her hair, impeccable, in a long, sleek ponytail.
After spotting the singular style maven, I started to believe that the event must have been poorly promoted. While I’m sure it was difficult to target the right demographic, the fact stands that a more youthful crowd should have been in attendance. I don't think any of them even knew the events were taking place.
For the show, both designers and retailers from the Madison area showed their goods. The only inventive designs on the runway came from 18 year-old local, Kayla Garland. Garland is the driving force behind Maverick Clothing, a line of uniquely reconstructed garments inspired by the designer's vintage finds.
On Maverick's runway, models were styled with hippie-ish knit hats, thin headbands with feathers, and vintage neck scarves, channeling the bohemian vibe that the rest of the weekend’s events were desperately lacking.
Obviously, there were obstacles, but Madison Fashion Week achieved what should have been their greatest goal. Through the events, they changed the perceptions of many style uncertain locals. I think with re-targeted promotion and due time, Madison Fashion Week has the ability to be the launchpad for making its city another great indie style destination.
The ambivalence stems from the fact that the two entities barely know each other and people rarely dare to introduce them. Living in the Midwest, you think we’d be used to hearing "fashion" said with discretion. It wasn't even until 2006 that Chicago, the Midwest's honorary fashion capitol, finally began hosting their own fashion week. And, just two years later, the Midwestern metropolis known better for cheese than clothes, followed suit.
In April 2008, Madison, Wisconsin held their very own fashion week. Runways, models, after parties and all! I was there, intrigued, hopeful and still apprehensive.
To make one thing clear, it wasn’t so much a fashion week as it was an extended weekend of fashion-inspired events. Workshops including, “Careers in Fashion”, “Celebrity Styling” and “Runway Ready Hair”, were intertwined with two runway events and an accessories show.
The main event was on a Saturday. Upon arrival I scanned the room to see what I was in for. Immediately, I noticed the sod-laden runway, which quickly went from charming to cheap. As I took my seat, I glanced over at my fellow front-rowers. I was overwhelmed with the lack of fashion forward youth. Isn’t that who the front row is for?
Instead, there was an abundance of “over 35” ladies dressed in poly-blend blouses and flared black pants, adorned in gobs of silver jewelry. Not that I think fashion should have an age limit but the entire week(end) seemed to lack the innovative youth culture that Madison is built on.
Down the row, I finally spotted a fellow fashionista. The woman, probably from out of town, wore a crisp white trench coat, black skirt, tights and heels. Her hair, impeccable, in a long, sleek ponytail.
After spotting the singular style maven, I started to believe that the event must have been poorly promoted. While I’m sure it was difficult to target the right demographic, the fact stands that a more youthful crowd should have been in attendance. I don't think any of them even knew the events were taking place.
For the show, both designers and retailers from the Madison area showed their goods. The only inventive designs on the runway came from 18 year-old local, Kayla Garland. Garland is the driving force behind Maverick Clothing, a line of uniquely reconstructed garments inspired by the designer's vintage finds.
On Maverick's runway, models were styled with hippie-ish knit hats, thin headbands with feathers, and vintage neck scarves, channeling the bohemian vibe that the rest of the weekend’s events were desperately lacking.
Obviously, there were obstacles, but Madison Fashion Week achieved what should have been their greatest goal. Through the events, they changed the perceptions of many style uncertain locals. I think with re-targeted promotion and due time, Madison Fashion Week has the ability to be the launchpad for making its city another great indie style destination.
Filed under:
Anonymous #2: Did you really just waste that much time criticizing someone? "And, unlike you, I'm in the buisness and will honestly critique it." She DID honestly critique it..just cause it didnt agree with your "in-the-business"(ha please) view doesn't mean shes "lying" about it. Also are you seriously attacking her picture? She didn't choose to put that one up actually. Maybe you have seen her around Madison? Ha yeah stop talking.
This article is exactly what the "fashion week" was! Yes i hope next year it will be better, but she wrote what she saw and why it wasn't mind-blowing impressing. I love your writing Maggie. Your articles are my favorite to read. Keep it up!
Just because some people don't support fashion, doesn't mean that MFW or any other fashion events are a complete waste of time. That's like saying that any political or social movement is a waste of time. And if you can find a movement that only supports a certain age group/race/gender, then it isn't a movement.
As for those of you writing horrendous disrespectful responses (not criticism, i'm talking bashing), I suggest you TRY to 1) organize something like this in a town like this and 2) get up on the fucking runway and walk it. I would LOVE to see you try. And for those of you who commented on the runway, have you ever heard of the words originality and creativity? In order to make an event (especially a groundbreaking one like this) memorable, you HAVE to have something different. The fact that you're targeting someone and insulting them just shows how insecure YOU are. Maggie we all appreciate your criticism, it is after all, journalism. And without opinion there would be no stepping stone to evolve. And isn't this what it's all about? We got great responses and reviews from the other media, we could do with an opposing opinion, it's just another way of showing your support ;). Madison Fashion Week wasn't just a place for fashionistas to share a passion, it was a revolution.
I don't think fashion has an age limit. In fact, I agree with Lisa. The greatest minds and faces in the industry are older, but they don't live anywhere near here. In Madison, style innovation and creativity is located within the younger sect—students from all over the world bringing and mixing their ideas and views. These are the people who will bring Madison Fashion Week full circle. Madison Fashion Week severely lacked representation from this population.
I can only imagine what an undertaking it must have been for one woman, Kristi, to put together and applaud her for doing it, someone had to. But it is rare for anything to be perfect the first time around. You go for it, see what works and what doesn't then try again, etc. As I state in my article, I believe this is a step forward and a great foundation to build on.
This is certainly not the most mean-spirited post I've read here, but neither is it the most well-informed; I've never read a style page where the writer failed to talk to other people at a fashion event (what did the lady in the white trench think about the show? you're publishing - a perfect excuse to approach and ask). I'd urge you to step outside your own perspective once in a while and see what people think beyond the tiny hipster world this blog looks out at the rest of the world from.
As for you you, ANONYMOUS #2, you were probably one of the poorly dressed women in the front row.
If you were really in the industry, you would post a link to your company's website so we could see your face.
I agree with Diane, leave Maggie alone. I guess if I was old and lived in Madison I would be bored enough to sit on my computer and talk shit about a young girl, too.
This website might not be "credible" in your eyes but it is NOT poorly done. At least they don't use a cheap, 90's template with some HORRIBLY dressed model as the focus. If that's what you chose to represent Madison, I feel like there may be some truth as to what Maggie wrote.
I guess there's a reason some people aren't New Yorkers.
Remove yourselves from your little bubble, grow some balls and get your shit together.
I also take issue with the belief that just because someone is young, they must have bad taste/only like things that are "cute". I didn't see Madison Fashion Week, but I feel Maggie's longing for something more cutting edge in the Midwest, as opposed to something mainstream and retail-oriented.
As a woman (24-years-old) in the industries, I find myself more and more intrigued, and inspired by age, experience, and wisdom. Sure, 20-year-old hotties are great arm candy, but are they the substance of fashion today? Absolutely not. In fact, I think the authors point about age just shows her lack of fashion authenticity, or experiance. (Karl Lagerfield, Betsy Johnson, Versace...all over 40 years old and still creating the most fashion-forward threads today.) Also, look at the fashion chaos that was stirred by the four most influential women in mainstream fashion: Carrie, Miranda, Charlotte and Samantha. I'd love a list of ground-breaking fashion designers/trend setters in the family today that are not influenced by our fashion big brothers and sisters? Miley Cyrus is cute and young, and I hear she has a clothing line coming out... I hope the author gets front row for her collection launch.
Post new comment